Vacation rentals in Cuttyhunk Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cuttyhunk Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

The main sleeping area features a spacious wooden bed with grey linens and two light blue towels neatly arranged on the bed. Two bedside tables with lamps flank the bed, and large windows with black shades provide a view of the greenery outside.

Guest suite in West Tisbury

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Studio Guest Suite in Modern Barn House

A beautiful guest suite on Martha’s Vineyard with a private entrance on the back wing of our newly renovated modern barn house. Surrounded by trees, beside a large meadow, this airy suite has vaulted wood ceilings with skylights. Enjoy the outdoor shower and new outdoor sitting area. The location is prime and centrally located, just off historic Music St, a short walk to our small town center which provides many amenities. Ask about our other private guest suite if you are traveling with others

Guest favorite

A spacious living room is highlighted by a large grey sectional couch adorned with various throw pillows. A wooden coffee table sits in front, featuring storage compartments. Two abstract paintings in calming blues are displayed above the couch, while soft lighting illuminates the area.

Guest suite in Oak Bluffs

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 379 reviews

Lovely 2 BR Oak Bluffs Apartment

This 100% private apartment is on the first floor of a shared house where owners and their son live upstairs. There are no shared spaces. You have a private entrance and parking. The living room, bedrooms, bathroom, and kitchenette are bright and clean. It is exactly 1 mile from Oak Bluffs Center, a half mile from The Cottages and Farm Neck Golf Course, and a block from Tradewinds walking trails. Across the street is the bike path, & the bus stop is on the corner for easy island transportation!

Top guest favorite

A charming entrance to a tiny house is bordered by vibrant flowers and greenery. Two blue chairs provide a seating area by the door, complemented by potted plants. The wooden deck appears inviting and well-maintained, enhancing access to the home.

Tiny home in Middletown

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Cozy coastal tiny house getaway

Situated on Easton's Point, brand new ocean front tiny house looks across to Mansion Row with access to a rocky beach for lounging, swimming, or fishing. The property is close to downtown Newport & ideally located between three beaches. The cozy unit has a queen bed, full bath & kitchenette with coffee maker, fridge, and toaster oven. There is a small deck with ocean views, access to ocean front, outdoor shower and off street parking. We provide beach chairs, a beach umbrella and towels.

Top guest favorite

A quaint historic home features classic shingle siding and a welcoming green front door. Windows with evenly spaced panes provide a glimpse of the interior, while a white picket fence and lush greenery frame the property, creating an inviting setting.

Home in Sandwich

5 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Quintessential Waterfront Historic Cottage

Set in a historic district and on a quiet pond shore, create memories with family and friends that will last a lifetime. Enjoy quintessential New England views from every angle. Coffee, restaurants, shopping & a fresh spring water fountain within a short walk to village center and under a mile to the nearest beach. Spend time walking the local area, exploring Cape Cod and relaxing in an atmospheric setting. Each room has been curated in a timeless tone, with relaxation and comfort in mind.

Top guest favorite

An open studio space features a cozy sleeping area with a spacious bed covered in light bedding. A soft armchair and a wooden bench provide additional seating. Natural light streams in from a window, enhancing the room's bright atmosphere. Shelving displays books and decorative items.

Apartment in Oak Bluffs

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 217 reviews

Sunny Studio Apartment on Martha's Vineyard

Our Sunny Studio is centrally located on Martha's Vineyard. A down-island location with an up-island feel. Open and airy studio with kitchenette and bath. The apartment has all the essentials. The apartment is located within walking distance of hiking and biking trails. A 10 to 15 minute car ride to any down-island town / beach. ***Please Note: Although conveniently located we are not within walking distance to Bars or Restaurants. We do recommend first time visitors rent or bring a car.

Top guest favorite

The open living area features exposed wooden beams overhead and includes a spacious wooden dining table. Two lounge chairs, a round pouf, and a day bed are arranged for seating. Natural light filters in through large glass doors, leading to an outdoor area.

Guesthouse in Chilmark

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

4-Season Guest House on Historic Chilmark Estate

Beautiful private guest house in Chilmark on Martha's Vineyard. Secluded yet convenient. Drive on pass to spectacular Chilmark beaches! Newly renovated and gorgeous. Great location - 10 minute walk to Chilmark Store. Full kitchen, living area, kitchen island/dining table, queen bed, day bed (not for sleeping), fireplace/heater, private outdoor shower, deck and picnic table, full bath inside. Keurig machine. 2 friendly labs/2 chickens on premises. Easy bus access. Old-style MV charm.

Top guest favorite

A spacious bedroom features a large king bed with a custom wood frame and soft bedding. Natural light enters through two windows with sheer curtains, and a colorful abstract art piece adorns the wall. A full-length mirror stands adjacent to the bed on a textured area rug.

Apartment in Falmouth

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

Modern Luxury Apt. | 7 min from Commons

This luxury 1Br + 1bth apartment is the perfect getaway. - 650 square feet, newly renovated - 15 Minutes from Old Silver Beach, South Cape Beach, and Falmouth Heights beaches - Steps from 1,700 acres of walking trails (Crane Wildlife) - 7 minutes to Mashpee Commons (shops and restaurants) - 15 minutes to Main Street Falmouth - 13 minutes to Ferry for Marthas Vineyard - 85” smart TV - 5 minutes to Shining Sea Bike Trail - Coffee/Espresso Machine - 2 minutes from Paul Harney Golf Course

Top guest favorite

A cozy outdoor seating area is arranged with several white lounge chairs on a gravel surface. A brick fireplace is positioned near the house, accompanied by potted plants and a view of the deck area adorned with covered furniture in the background.

Cottage in Tisbury

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 344 reviews

Martha's Vineyard Getaway Cottage

Contemporary cottage on quiet, private, wooded lot. Pristine, bright & comfortably furnished. Open living area, hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings, indoor/outdoor fireplaces, well appointed kitchen, washer/dryer, cable/internet/phone with unlimited national calling, SmartTV with Netflix and additional internet streaming services. Walk or bike to beaches and trails, 5 minute drive from downtown shops and restaurants. Property abuts West Chop Woods with lovely, quiet walking trails.

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features a stone fireplace, with a muted flame providing a warm glow. Above, a flat-screen TV is mounted against white shiplap walls, complemented by exposed beams. A dark wood coffee table sits at the center, surrounded by comfortable seating and decorative accents.

Home in New Bedford

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 248 reviews

Historic Cobblestone Carriage House near Downtown

Enjoy a piece of history at this carriage house! Jonathan Bourne owned a mansion along with this home, and his son purchased a whaler, Lagoda, in 1841. The ship is currently displayed at the New Bedford Whaling Museum, which is walking distance; just four/five blocks of downtown New Bedford, where you can also enjoy shopping, great food, entertainment, and the ferry to either Martha’s Vineyard or Nantucket. New 2025 (MBTA) commuter train rail to Boston and more. Check it out!

Guest favorite

A charming farmhouse is set against a backdrop of autumn foliage, featuring vibrant trees and a cloudy sky. A garden with various plants and flowers is visible in the foreground, adding natural texture to the scene.

Loft in Westport

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 300 reviews

Brithaven Farm

Brithaven Farm is on 28 acres of fields, woods meadows and gardens. We are just 2 miles from East Beach and the Allen's Pond Wildlife Sanctuary. We are completely private from the road and reached by a long laneway through woods which opens up to fields and meadows The rental has 2 decks, one with a large awning with dining table and chairs to lounge and take in the view. There is an open plan living, dining kitchen area with french doors leading to the deck.

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features a comfortable gray sofa with decorative pillows and a wooden coffee table. Natural light fills the space, highlighting a dining table with four chairs. A doorway leads to the kitchen, while a wall-mounted TV provides entertainment options.

Guest suite in Falmouth

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

The Sea-Cret Garden, Guest Apartment

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space! This comfortable and peaceful guest apartment is situated in an ideal location in a quiet, beautiful neighborhood that is close to beaches and a short drive to downtown. Take a quick stroll to the West Falmouth Market or the Shining Sea Bike Path. With easy access to Chapoquoit & Old Silver Beach, this perfectly situated apartment is in an ideal spot for your next Falmouth getaway!

Guest favorite

A charming cottage exterior is presented, featuring shingle siding and a welcoming wraparound deck. Outdoor seating includes a picnic table and several armchairs surrounded by planters with blooming flowers. Large windows provide ample natural light, enhancing the inviting atmosphere of the space.

Home in Little Compton

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Salt box

Come and Relax! Newly renovated guest cottage in little Compton, Rhode Island on a quiet dead end street. Access to beach, close to town commons, farmers market and Sakonnet and Westport wineries among other special spots. Wonderful walking and biking area. Perfect for couples or a small family to get away. Special note...Memorial Day to Columbus Day house includes a beach pass to Briggs beach. More info will be shared as needed.