Vacation rentals in Butler Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Butler Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A serene outdoor space features a patio table surrounded by chairs, set against the calm waters of Metcalf Pond. A large umbrella provides shade, while an American flag gently flutters nearby. The backdrop includes rolling hills adorned with autumn colors.
Cottage in Fletcher
5 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Metcalf Pond Camp Convenient to Smugglers Notch

Handcrafted cozy waterfront camp on Metcalf pond. Propane fireplace provides for welcome warmth after fall or winter adventures. Soak in the Hot tub on the deck. Custom spiral staircase accesses carpeted sleeping loft with books, TV, rocking chair. Enjoy the quiet off season brings to the area when most camps are shuttered for winter. Enjoy staying in and cooking and taking in the cozy atmosphere or make the approximately 20 minute drive to Smugglers Notch or enjoy other local attractions.

Top guest favorite
An aerial view captures a lush green landscape along the shoreline of Lake Champlain, featuring a blend of trees in fall colors. A spacious property is outlined by a rocky shoreline, with Adirondack chairs arranged on the grass near the water, providing a picturesque outdoor gathering spot.
Guest suite in Grand Isle
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 450 reviews

Private Lakefront Suite - A Winter Wonderland!

Welcome to VT’s most beautiful lakefront property! Relax in one of many Adirondack chairs while enjoying incredible sunsets over Lake Champlain and the ADK Mtns. The 1 BR suite shares no space with the main home and has its own entrance and bathroom. Just imagine having one of VT’s premier lakefront wedding venues all to yourself. Just bring the s’mores to toast at our lakeside fire pit. You certainly will not be disappointed! Please read the full description about the rental prior to booking.

Top guest favorite
Aerial view of the vibrant Vermont landscape, showcasing rolling hills adorned with a diverse palette of fall foliage. The rustic barn sits among expansive fields, framed by trees displaying bright autumn colors, with distant mountains in the background under a partly cloudy sky.
Barn in Morristown
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

200 acre Stowe area Bunkhouse.

Hello and welcome to our Red Road Farm 'Bunkhouse' -- We're so happy to host you! Sitting on our 200 acre estate this authentic barn offers our guests a chance to relax in the beautiful rolling hills of Vermont. Access the vast majority of our historic Stowe area land -- from our apple orchards to our extensive walking paths in fields and woodland. We hope that you can experience such fun and quiet time in our cozy, western-style bunk room. Located only a 10 minute drive from downtown Stowe.

Guest favorite
A charming cottage is surrounded by well-maintained gardens and trees, showcasing a sloped roof and inviting front porch. Nearby, a gazebo can be seen within a spacious, fenced yard, complemented by a green lawn and a rustic wooden fence.
Cottage in Alburgh
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

Storybook Cottage in the Champlain Islands

The perfect Champlain Island getaway! Storybook cottage is an enchanting little spot located on “Point of the Tongue” - a narrow strip of land that juts down into Lake Champlain from Canada. One hour north to Montreal, 40 minutes south to Burlington and a short walk to Alburgh Dunes State Park - a hidden treasure! Come in summer to swim, fish, bike, hike and relax in the idyllic surroundings. Come in winter for the magical peace and quiet. Come and write your own story at Storybook Cottage!

Top guest favorite
A charming cottage is nestled among tall trees, partially hidden in a snowy landscape. Warm light emanates from the windows, contrasting with the snow-covered ground, creating a welcoming scene in the serene forest setting.
Guest suite in Waterville
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

Rivers Rock - a charming cottage in the woods

Warm, charming cottage, impeccably furnished with spacious cook's kitchen, nestled in a serene wooded hollow. Enjoy the cozy warmth of the gas fireplace in winter, the cool respite of river wading in summer, or brisk nights around the firepit after a day enjoying gorgeous fall foliage or biking on the Lamoille Valley Rail Trail. While rural, you're central: Smugglers Notch Resort 18 minutes, Jay Peak 30 minutes, Stowe Mountain Resort 40 minutes, Jeffersonville's art galleries 10 minutes.

Guest favorite
A modern kitchen is presented, featuring dark green cabinetry and a wooden dining table with black metal chairs. Natural light enters through two windows, illuminating a refrigerator and white microwave. A vibrant red rug adds a pop of color to the wooden floor.
Home in Alburgh
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Private, Cozy House!

Newly renovated 600 square foot house features a heat pump, WIFI, new flooring fresh paint, and comfortable furniture to kick back and relax in. We have a fully stocked kitchen, a 40 inch TV with Roku, a gas grill and all linens and towels are included. Boat launch and Alburg Sand Beach (the dunes) is about 3 minutes as well. Harborside Market has all the essentials. Explore the local restaurant scene. Visit The North Hero House, Shore Acres or The Blue Paddle for a delicious meal.

Guest favorite
The exterior of Alder Brook Cottage is shown, featuring rustic wooden siding and a metal roof. A wooden footbridge leads to the front door, surrounded by trees and patches of snow. Bright windows are visible, enhancing the cabin's inviting appearance.
Tiny home in Hardwick
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 233 reviews

Alder Brook Cottage: A Tiny House in the Woods

From the moment you cross the cedar footbridge over Alder Brook, you'll know you're somewhere special. Featured in Boston Magazine and CabinPorn, Alder Brook Cottage is an inspired, rustic dream cabin located in the woods of Vermont's Northeast Kingdom. Surrounded by a crystal clear stream and 1400 acres of rugged forest, it is the perfect getaway for glampers looking to experience the tiny house life. Minutes away from Caspian Lake, Hill Farmstead Brewery & Craftsbury Outdoor Center.

Top guest favorite
Two unique chalet structures, designed with a modern aesthetic, are situated on a sloped landscape. The buildings feature angular shapes and large glass windows, which reflect the surrounding forest, inviting nature indoors. The ground is covered with natural foliage and rocks.
Chalet in West Bolton
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

The Binocular: Peaceful Architect Cottage

Cosy timeless chalet conceptualized by the architects of _naturehumaine. Nestled into the cliffside at an altitude of 490 meters (1600 feet), its unique design is distinguished by boldness and originality and fits with harmony in its environment. Surrounded by forest, the cottage offers breathtaking views of Mount Glen and the surrounding nature largely protected by the Appalachian Corridor. The perfect silent place to relax and unwind. Photo: Adrien Williams / S.A. CITQ #302449

Guest favorite
A cozy sleeping area is featured with a spacious bed dressed in a blue patterned coverlet. A wooden nightstand and lamp provide gentle illumination, while a quaint heater adds warmth. A neutral area rug and decorative elements enhance the rustic charm of the space.
Apartment in Fairfield
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

Historic Farmhouse Apartment - 7min to St. Albans

Rustic and stylish accessory apartment on a picturesque Vermont farm. Find peace and rejuvenation in this charming pastoral getaway. Conveniently located just 7 minutes from beautiful downtown St. Albans, historic landmarks and nature preserves of Fairfield, VT. Only 20 minutes from the Canadian boarder. Surround yourself in the breathtaking views of the Vermont countryside, the Green Mountains, and Lake Champlain on your way to and from this slice of maple country heaven.

Guest favorite
A hot tub is positioned with a view of the lake, surrounded by trees and an open landscape. The water is calm, reflecting the colors of the sky. In the distance, a dock is visible along the shoreline.
Home in Saint Albans City
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Sunrise Lake House! Comfort-Hot Tub-Beach

Relax and recharge with family and friends at the lake! It’s the perfect place to stay year round. We aim to provide a place of comfort and relaxation with essential and fun amenities. Enjoy private lakefront access, a screened porch to relax on, kayaks and paddle boards provided in the summer. Enjoy the NEW 4 person Hot Tub with Lake views! Minutes to downtown St. Albans, offering delicious eateries and shopping at local boutiques. Burlington is 35 minutes away.

Top guest favorite
A rustic cabin with a wooden exterior is surrounded by lush greenery. The inviting porch features several rocking chairs and is accessed by steps from a grassy area, while a gravel driveway leads to the entrance, enhancing the private setting.
Cabin in Wolcott
5 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Meadow Woods Cabin, private, cozy and unconnected

Enjoy beautiful sunsets from your rocking chair on the cabin's wonderful porch. There is a large, well equipped kitchen, open space floor plan, new shower unit and plenty of closet space in the bedroom. Easy access to VAST snowmobile trails, within an hour's drive to 3 ski areas (Stowe, Smuggler's Notch and Jay Peak), X-Country skiing right outside the door or in Craftsbury or Stowe. Elmore State Park is 3 miles away. Hiking trails and kayaking abound!

Top guest favorite
A lone fisherman is silhouetted in a kayak, cast against the backdrop of a vibrant sunset over the calm waters of Lake Champlain. The sky features warm hues of orange and gold, reflecting softly on the water's surface.
Guesthouse in Highgate
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 705 reviews

Beautiful lake-front cottage, Lake Champlain

Lakefront cottage located in Highgate Springs, Vermont, on the Canadian border. The 2-bedroom cottage sits adjacent to the owner-occupied main house, on a large one-acre lot, with 120 feet of Lake Champlain shoreline. Enjoy the stunning sunset views while sitting on the deck overlooking the water. Private dock included. Montreal and Burlington each 45 minutes away. Available level-2 car charger. Well-behaved pets allowed. Super-fast WIFI!

Popular amenities for Butler Island vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Vermont
  4. Grand Isle County
  5. North Hero
  6. Butler Island