Places to stay near Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

Book unique vacation rentals, homes, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals near Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
An exterior view of the Wana House showcases the two-story structure, surrounded by green lawns and trees. A spacious yard is visible, with nearby barns and an inviting landscape reflecting a peaceful countryside setting.
Home in Shipshewana
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

The-WANA-House: Shipshe/Amish owned: 6 bed 2 bath

Experience a bit of the Amish lifestyle yet with a few modern touches. Disconnect from the digital world and embrace the joy of conversation, board games, and simply being present in the moment. Surrounded by picturesque fields, you'll wake up to the harmonious sounds of nature and a breathtaking view every morning. Owned by WANA Cabinet & Furniture (next door), the Wana House is a 2-minute drive to Shipshewana’s main strip and the MEC center. It’s a perfect place to visit w/friends and family!

Top guest favorite
A modern bar area features a wooden countertop with seating for four. A smart TV is mounted on the wall, surrounded by shelves. Soft lighting is provided by pendant lamps. A cozy seating arrangement is visible in the background, enhancing the inviting space.
Guest suite in Shipshewana
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Cozy Industrial Farmhouse Walkout Basement

A newly renovated basement guest suite in the heart of Amish Country. Enjoy playing pool and a 60"TV during your stay. 1 mile from town and 34 miles from Notre Dame stadium. Enjoy a morning walk around the block and campfire in the evening. Playset and in-ground trampoline. Private entrance. One queen bed with futon and/or air mattress. Living room with smart TV, WiFi, cozy elec. fireplace, AC, elec. heat. Kitchenette with fridge, microwave, coffee maker /griddle /toaster oven. (No kitchen sink)

Guest favorite
Home in Goshen
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

The Cozy Townhouse

Welcome to The Cozy Townhouse located in Goshen. Centrally located to Middlebury, Nappanee, and Shipshewana, this will be the perfect place to settle down for the night. The property has a closed in backyard fence with a fireplace where you can enjoy your evenings. Whether you are staying with family or with friends this will be a great stay for you. Wake up and enjoy a fresh cup of coffee with grounds from local coffee shop Main Street Roasters which is located in Nappanee. 40 minutes from ND.

Top guest favorite
A single-story house is set on a green lawn, with a well-maintained front garden featuring pink flowering shrubs. The brick exterior complements the surrounding foliage, and a pathway leads to the front door, framed by a modest porch.
Home in Shipshewana
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 442 reviews

Davis Street in Shipshewana

Davis Street in Shipshewana, located in the heart of Shipshewana Indiana's Amish country. Very close to the Auction & Flea Market, and within walking distance to local theatre, shops and restaurants. We offer cozy and friendly accommodations for the perfect country getaway. A perfect place to relax and enjoy partaking of the local small town pleasures. Access to the Pumpkinvine Nature Hiking/Biking trail is just 1 mile. And just 40 miles from Notre Dame/South Bend. (for the Irish football fans)

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area features comfortable seating arranged around a coffee table. A large television is mounted on the wall, and natural light filters in through the glass doors leading to a patio. Decorative plants add a touch of greenery.
Home in Shipshewana
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

The Frey House

PLEASE READ GUEST ACCESS BEFORE BOOKING..... Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun. Located just 5 minutes from Blue Gate Theater and the Michiana Event Center. Only 3 minutes to the down town shops which includes the Vanilla Bean Icecream shop. 45 minutes from Notre Dame. With in walking distance to the Pumpkin Vine bike trail. Wake up in the morning and make a fresh cup of coffee as you sit at the kitchen table watching the horse drawn buggies drive past .

Top guest favorite
A welcoming front porch features two rocking chairs positioned beside a small decorative table, adorned with bright pink flowers. Lush greenery is visible in nearby planters, while sunlit windows with green shutters complete the charming country setting.
Guest suite in Shipshewana
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 594 reviews

Picket Fence Farm Private Guest Retreat Suite

Stay in a 2nd story private suite in a modern farmhouse where we reside on a family farm in Amish country. Guests have the entire 2nd floor: 2 bedrooms, a private bath, and a sitting room. You can watch Amish buggies drive by while you rock on the front porch, access shared patio spaces or sit by a creek. We have cows, goats & chickens. We're in the heart of Shipshewana Amish/Mennonite community, minutes from downtown Shipshewana & all it has. An authentic, comfortable country getaway.

Top guest favorite
Farm stay in Vandalia
5 out of 5 average rating, 283 reviews

Couples country stay, Private, Hot Tub, Creek,

*Imagine soaking in your private hot tub under the stars while a gentle creek flows just steps away. You are surrounded by trees and natural beauty. *Situated on 70 acres with flowing creek *Pickle Ball court 1 mile from Binn *Fully stocked kitchen *Fireplace *Hot tub with towels provided * Firepit with firewood *Bird feeder for Bird lovers *King size bed with quality bedding *Forgot something? Got cha *In floor heat *Snacks *Walking trails *Good WIFI *Unplug to reconnect

Guest favorite
Tiny home in Shipshewana
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Private Lake+Fire Pit+Sauna+Kayaks | Pine & Paddle

Welcome to Pine and Paddle — the perfect place to unplug, recharge, and reconnect with nature by the lake. Unwind at this cozy lakeside tiny home, perfect for couples, friends, or solo travelers seeking peace, nature, and a hint of adventure near downtown Shipshewana. 🔥 Campfire pad w/ firewood + lake views 🛶 Kayaks + fishing poles + private dock ♨️ Wooden barrel sauna for ultimate relaxation 🌳 Private lake, beach, & outdoor games 🛏️ Sleeps 5 w/ full-size bunks + couch

Top guest favorite
A cozy studio apartment features a comfortable bed with soft linens, a wooden coffee table, and a light-colored chest of drawers. Natural light filters in through a nearby window, illuminating the space. A green armchair is positioned in one corner, adding to the inviting ambiance.
Loft in Shipshewana
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 364 reviews

Hidden Country Hide-A-Way

Come relax in our cozy, modern country, studio apartment. It is  equipt with a fully stocked kitchenette, private bathroom, comfortable living space, large screen tv and office work space.  Enjoy some of the most picturesque landscape Northern Indiana has to offer.  We are just a 10 min walk from Stone Lake and have kayak rentals available upon request.  We are conveniently located 8 miles from Shipshewana and Middlebury, IN and just a 40 minute drive from Notre Dame.

Top guest favorite
Home in Shipshewana
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 363 reviews

The Oasis in Shipshewana

Enjoy the benefits of a furnished home during your stay! The perfect spot to enjoy a quiet place yet very close to local attractions in Shipshewana. The Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market is within walking distance. This is an ideal house for families looking for an economical vacation stay. A large deck and backyard for you to enjoy the outdoors. Bring your bicycles and take a ride on the Pumpkinvine Nature hiking and biking trail nearby. No TV but no time to miss it!

Top guest favorite
A comfortable living area features two soft sofas positioned around a light area rug. Natural light enters through a large window adorned with patterned curtains. A modern television sits on a wooden stand, and a lamp is placed beside a side table.
Apartment in Howe
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 259 reviews

The Upper Room

A newly remodeled full above-garage apartment with private entrance and access to a one car garage with a secure key pad. Only 15 minutes from Shipshewana Trading Place which is home to the midwest's largest flea market, beautiful Pumpkinvine Nature Trail amid Amish inspired shops and cuisine. Minutes from Indiana toll road exit 121 this quiet wooded setting is a great choice for an extended stay or ideal for a special getaway.

Top guest favorite
A charming log cabin features a welcoming facade with large windows framed by wooden accents. The entrance is accessed via a stone pathway lined with landscaped garden beds, showcasing lush greenery and colorful plants. Surrounding trees provide a serene, natural setting.
Cabin in Middlebury
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 428 reviews

Cabin off 39 - Peaceful, private one bedroom cabin

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Nestled among the trees, it provides a quiet getaway from the chaos of life allowing you to recharge and renew. The main residence is approximately 400 feet from the cabin. The cabin is secluded and yet close to local attractions, restaurants, biking and nature trails. The Cabin has a total of 420 sq ft living space with 280 sq ft on the ground floor and a 140 sq ft bedroom loft.

Popular amenities for vacation rentals near Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery